Analysis: Roe v. Wade's foundation might be shaky but that doesn't mean it will fall
The Roe opinion wonders aloud if this bundle of rights is inferred from the 14th Amendment's concept of personal liberty, or the Ninth Amendment's reservation of rights to the people. Uncertainty about the legal source of those rights didn't stop the court from extending a new privacy right to a woman's decision to terminate her pregnancy.
Another criticism of Roe is that when unelected judges infer new fundamental rights from the shadows of other rights, judges override the local democratic process, and silence the voices of the voters in states such as Alabama. These arguments will appeal to justices such as Neil Gorsuch and Clarence Thomas, for whom the original meaning of the text of a statute is its only meaning.
The Alabama statute has been criticized for omitting exceptions to the ban in cases of rape or incest. That omission was a strategic one: By removing these exceptions, the Alabama law is grounded in the principle that a fertilized egg is a life. For those against abortion, a rape/incest exception is a logical inconsistency: Life is life, whether or not the child’s father was a rapist. The exemption tees up the argument for the Supreme Court: Roe v.
Österreich Neuesten Nachrichten, Österreich Schlagzeilen
Similar News:Sie können auch ähnliche Nachrichten wie diese lesen, die wir aus anderen Nachrichtenquellen gesammelt haben.
Alabama’s lawmakers want to challenge Roe v WadeAlabama's Senate passed a bill that would ban abortion outright, including in cases of rape or incest
Weiterlesen »
Supreme Court is not eager to overturn Roe vs. Wade — at least not soonSupreme Court justices have many ways to avoid making sweeping rulings. Chief Justice Roberts has typically resisted moving quickly to decide major controversies or to announce abrupt, far-reaching changes in the law.
Weiterlesen »
Klobuchar on 'The View': 'extremely concerned' about fate of Roe vs. WadeSen. Amy Klobuchar says she’s “extremely concerned” that recent abortion bans could overturn Roe v. Wade: “They’re taking us backwards... This was a movement [Trump] started and that’s why this 2020 election is so important.”
Weiterlesen »
Analysis | In Alabama, the GOP goes big on overturning Roe v. Wade. It could regret it.Republicans in other states have argued for a more incremental approach. Alabama abandoned all pretenses this week.
Weiterlesen »
Alabama's Abortion Law Signed By Governor, Sets Stage For Roe ChallengeAlabama governor Kay Ivey just signed the country's most restrictive abortion law, specifically written to make its way up to the highest court
Weiterlesen »
Alabama's Abortion Law Signed By Governor, Sets Stage For Roe ChallengeThe measure would be the most restrictive anti-abortion law in the country.
Weiterlesen »
Alabama's Abortion Law Signed By Governor, Sets Stage For Roe ChallengeThe measure would be the most restrictive anti-abortion law in the country.
Weiterlesen »